Skip to content
Ata Daee
← Back to the town

UX/UI Design · 2022

Exploring Comfort through XAI

A case study on managing and controlling heating systems for optimal thermo-comfort.

Role
UX/UI Design
Year
2022
Duration
6 months
Target group
Full-time employees
Tools
Figma, Miro, Canva
Type
Academic conceptual (Univ. of Siegen)

The Smart Heating System revolutionizes home heating, offering remote temperature control via smartphones. Compatible with various thermostats, it enables users to adjust room or whole-home temperatures effortlessly. Scheduling and voice commands via smart home assistants streamline operation. Real-time usage monitoring aids in optimizing energy consumption, ensuring cost savings. Experience enhanced comfort and energy efficiency with the Smart Heating System.

Creating an end-to-end application that allows users to control their heating system from anywhere in the house. Connecting the device to their mobile phone enables them to adjust the temperature even when they are not at home. This helps save energy and provides detailed reports of their energy usage.

Many households face the challenge of inefficient heating systems that lack remote accessibility, leading to wasted energy and discomfort. Residents often struggle to control their heating when away from home, resulting in unnecessary energy consumption and increased utility bills. Additionally, the absence of detailed energy usage reports makes it difficult for users to monitor and optimize their heating habits effectively. Consequently, there is a pressing need for an end-to-end solution that empowers users to remotely manage their heating systems, reduce energy wastage, and gain insights into their energy usage patterns.

Below are the areas I wanted to explore during the user research we wanted to understand: The willingness of people to acquire smart heating system What are the user's motivations behind the shift from normal to smart heating system The options users are expecting from their smart heating system The user's goals when searching for smart heating options

The methodology involved conducting comprehensive user interviews with a diverse pool of 12 candidates who expressed interest in smart heating systems, each representing various stages of the project's development. All participants fell within the age range of 25 to 35 and held master's degrees, either actively engaged in full-time employment or pursuing further studies.

Competitive audit

↑ Back to overview

In the competitive audit, we analyzed existing smart heating systems, considering features, prices, and customer feedback. This process pinpointed areas for improving our app. We also tracked emerging industry trends and ideas. User research revealed a gap: no existing apps offered a report section. This insight underscored the necessity of including it for our users.

Product roadmap from the competitive audit

We were amazed at how much users were concerned about energy-saving. They see the tangible benefits of cost savings and environmental impact. By highlighting the potential cost savings and environmental benefits of energy conservation within the app, we can motivate users to use the app regularly and make energy-saving behavior a part of their daily routine

KWL chart capturing the research insights

From user interviews, we confirmed the project's direction and pinpointed a key feature to meet a critical need. While immediate availability of new features isn't urgent, aiding users in making informed heating decisions, particularly for quick adjustments, presents an opportunity. This will optimize energy use and enhance comfort.

Once we organized the findings from the research using the affinity map, we developed a persona to embody the primary user demographic.

Inspired by user research, market analysis, and personal empathy, I crafted a use case for my persona. Meet Mary, a working mom caught in the morning rush. With the smart heating app, she adjusts the thermostat remotely, saving energy while the house is empty. Throughout the day, reminders prompt her to set the temperature for her kids' return. Come evening, she optimizes comfort and efficiency by programming the thermostat for bedtime. Mary values the app's convenience, empowering her to manage her family's comfort and energy costs effortlessly.

During our brainstorming session, we came up with different ideas to fully understand the problem. We explored concepts that could be relevant to everyone and then refined them to make them specific to our target audience. At this stage, we carefully planned the entire process, from start to finish.

Brainstorming and affinity-mapping board

Low-fi Prototype & Improvement

↑ Back to overview

The initial iteration of low-fidelity wireframes enabled us to conduct early usability tests and identify crucial revisions that required immediate implementation. This streamlined the iterative process for subsequent versions, allowing us to focus efforts on developing the high-fidelity interface

Low-fidelity wireframes

Hi-fi Prototype & testing

↑ Back to overview

During our brainstorming session, we came up with different ideas to fully understand the problem. We explored concepts that could be relevant to everyone and then refined them to make them specific to our target audience. At this stage, we carefully planned the entire process, from start to finish, and implemented the feedback we gathered from our previous usability tests.

High-fidelity prototype shown on an iPadHigh-fidelity app screens

Usability testing

↑ Back to overview

We tested the first version of the prototype with 6 users to determine the necessary revisions to make the overall experience more intuitive and pleasant in 3 different stages making the improvements based on the feedback at each stage and continuing until we reached a final design.

Usability testing notes and design iterations

Recognizing the importance of valuing user insights and feedback above personal assumptions was a significant lesson. Additionally, acquiring adept skills in managing independent projects was crucial for ensuring effective and meaningful progress.

One limitation of the project using XAI for smart heating systems is explaining decisions when things get complicated. It's hard to be clear and accurate when there are many factors involved, like how users behave and what the environment is like. In the university research at the University of Siegen, this project is part of a bigger research effort. Making our suggested idea happen takes a long time.

🔒 Full findings available on request after publication.

Thanks for going through this journey with me. :)

Next projectChef Antonio